September 14, 2026 • 9:03 AM EDT
Updated 1 hours ago
If you’re looking for the next big thing in hockey, you don’t have to look much further than Matthew Schaefer. The NHL Network just dropped its latest Top 50 Players list before the 2026-27 season, and Schaefer, now in his second year, is already sitting at No. 28. That means the Islanders’ young defenseman is not just hype — he’s production, potential, and historical impact all rolled into one.
That’s not just good news for Islanders fans, it’s massive for any bettor searching for early edges. Schaefer’s leap in the rankings puts him ahead of a lot of more established names and past Olympians, showing just how quickly he’s changed the landscape.
According to Yahoo Sports, Schaefer comes in ahead of players like Jake Sanderson and Moritz Seider, and sits right behind Lane Hutson. That’s a serious vote of confidence from the analysts, considering Schaefer’s just 19 and already being measured against gold-medal winners and established NHL pros.
Last year, Schaefer put up 23 goals and 59 points through a full 82-game season. That didn’t just top the Islanders’ rookie records — it shattered scoring records for every 18-year-old defenseman the league has ever seen and landed him the Calder Trophy for best rookie. The last Islander to do that was Mathew Barzal all the way back in 2018, so you’re seeing the start of something historic here.
The ranking release is part of the NHL Network’s countdown, where each Sunday another batch of 10 players is revealed until the top 10 comes out September 27. Schaefer is the only rookie to make the list this year, which says everything about how dominant his rookie campaign really was. It’s rare to see a defenseman that young leapfrog both veterans and other breakout players this fast.
Schaefer won’t be the only Islander ranked. Goaltender Ilya Sorokin landed at No. 35 last week, but Schaefer is now the team’s highest-ranked player for 2026. He’s already set the bar sky-high and shows no signs of letting up. The player himself is embracing the challenge, saying he’s only focused on getting “bigger, stronger, faster” for his second act. It’s everything you want to hear if you’re considering a player prop or Islanders futures bet.
Why Schaefer’s Ranking Matters to Bettors
- Schaefer sits above decorated Olympians and established stars despite only one NHL season.
- His point total as an 18-year-old shattered all historical marks for rookie defensemen.
- As the only rookie on the NHL Network’s top 50, his impact is being recognized even by conservative analysts.
- He’s now top dog on the Islanders, outshining even the team’s star goaltender in these rankings.
- Schaefer’s commitment to improvement means there’s real upside — he’s not just a one-season wonder.
Islanders’ Outlook Could Shift Fast
With Schaefer ascending this quickly, you’ve got to ask yourself whether the Islanders’ odds — for games, prop bets, or even division futures — are being priced accurately. Bookmakers do adjust, but the real-time impact of star power is often underbaked after just one breakout year. If you’re trying to find value, betting on continued or even improved production from Schaefer is a smart angle, especially considering his relentless drive to get “bigger, stronger, faster.”
Key Takeaways for Bettors
- Matthew Schaefer is the youngest player in the NHL Network’s top 30 — that’s historic upside.
- He’s already Islander’s top-ranked player ahead of even their elite goaltender.
- A rookie season with 23 goals, 59 points, and a Calder Trophy puts Schaefer on a superstar trajectory.
- The NHL Network believes in his immediate and future impact, so oddsmakers will start catching up.
- If you like betting player props or futures, consider Schaefer for points, goals, or seasonal awards again.
- Monitor how the Islanders are priced game to game — Schaefer’s presence may boost team totals or affect spreads.
- Schaefer’s own attitude about improving means he’s a safer bet for continued growth than your average breakout star.
More coverage: latest NHL news, NHL betting hub and NHL expert picks.
Related stories
21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.
Login 
