Jacob Markstrom Trade Shifts New Jersey Devils Odds: Early 2026 Season Fade Is Now Live

NHL Jacob Markstrom Trade Shifts New Jersey Devils Odds: Early 2026 Season Fade Is Now Live

By Richard Gale

September 5, 2026 • 3:21 PM EDT

Updated 2 hours ago

Jacob Markstrom Trade Shifts New Jersey Devils Odds: Early 2026 Season Fade Is Now Live

Markstrom Gone, Allen In: What the New Jersey Devils Just Told Bettors for 2026

The New Jersey Devils traded Jacob Markstrom to the Florida Panthers on Monday, September 4, 2026, leaving Jake Allen as their primary goaltender heading into the season. What looks like an ordinary roster move is anything but routine for bettors: this shuffle turns New Jersey’s early-market odds on their head.

Allen is now the guy. The BDL LIVE_DATA feed confirms Markstrom is off the roster, Allen is healthy, and the only backups in the building are Nico Daws and veteran David Rittich, neither carrying Markstrom’s track record. This is a major net downgrade in proven reliability for a team projected as a playoff contender just last month.

Here’s where it hits your bets: the Devils’ moneyline and seasonal win totals aren’t yet reflecting Allen’s history. Every time Allen’s asked to carry the mail over more than 30-35 starts, the numbers sag: his save percentage and GAA spike when he’s overloaded. If oddsmakers cling to the previous Markstrom-era lines, sharp bettors have a two-week window for value fading the Devils, especially in back-to-backs or when Allen’s stretched. Game totals are in play too: if Allen or Daws struggle with the old workload, expect more overs to hit.

The Devils’ Goaltending Depth Is a Liability, Not a Luxury

The narrative says Allen gives the Devils “fresh legs and a new identity.” The data says his win-loss drops off with each consecutive start post-trade deadline in previous years. Daws has shown flashes in short relief but flagged in his only extended run. Rittich, meanwhile, has cycled through teams on one-year deals for a reason: he’s not a solution for a playoff push in 2026.

Don’t let optimism around youth or a no-name backup sway you. The difference between Markstrom and Allen isn’t theoretical: it’s visible on the expected-goals ledger and NHL-level save charts. Until Allen’s durability is proved over a 45-game pace, skepticism is the only rational move with your moneyline and win-total bets.

Key Developments Bettors Can’t Ignore

Markstrom shipped to Florida: removes a clear above-average starter from the Devils’ roster, deflates their win ceiling.
Allen set for 40+ starts: save % typically dips when asked for heavy service, Downgrade Devils’ projected results in those windows.
Daws and Rittich are depth, not solutions: neither has posted league-average numbers across a full NHL workload.
No major goalie injuries at publication: no hidden bounce or safety valve left on the bench for New Jersey.
Market unlikely to reprice fast: early-season moneyline and game totals may lag behind actual on-ice reality, exploit the discrepancy.

This Is an Early-Season Fade Opportunity, Don’t Let Narrative Win

The market’s first reaction after a goalie move is always narrative: “addition by subtraction,” “new day in the room,” or “young guns ready.” Ignore it. Allen’s last full-season starting stints saw performance correction within 10-15 games, and Daws was exposed any time his workload ramped above backup levels. If you let hope or PR control your hand, you’re on the wrong side of value early in 2026.

My read on this: fade the Devils on opening moneylines and be aggressive about undershooting their win totals if you still find the same pricing you did last week. The structural drop-off is more than reputation. Watch for early over opportunities in games Allen is confirmed for tight turnarounds or where Daws draws a surprise start, the value will vanish by Thanksgiving if you don’t act.

Key Takeaways

Fade the Devils moneyline in the first 10 games unless oddsmakers drop the pricing below last season’s Markstrom baseline.
Target the Devils season-under for win total if the number still reflects high-30s after the Markstrom trade.
Watch for early overs in game totals, Allen and Daws are unproven as heavy-workload stoppers.
Monitor Allen’s back-to-back appearances for fatigue spot plays.
Avoid all Devils goalie props until Allen proves his health over a full starter slate.
Back opposing team overs when Rittich is confirmed as starter.
Track Devils injury updates before betting unders, depth is thin and one setback will widen the value gap against them.

“You lose a guy like Markstrom and that’s a lot of games, a lot of leadership gone.”Eastern Conference NHL scout

This article was produced with AI assistance by Richard Gale (senior gambling industry executive and ThePicks founder), with editorial standards and betting methodology overseen by Ben Gale, and reviewed by the ThePicks editorial team. All statistics sourced from live BDL API data and verified source material. All betting opinions are those of ThePicks analysts.

https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/goals-jersey-devils-goaltenders-roster-170000985.html

21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.

Frequently Asked Questions

The New Jersey Devils traded Jacob Markstrom to the Florida Panthers to clear salary and move forward with Jake Allen as their starting goaltender. The move is aimed at focusing on new talent and providing Allen a shot at the number one role. This reshapes New Jersey’s roster and betting outlook.

Jake Allen becoming the Devils’ number one goalie means the team loses Markstrom’s stability and relies on Allen’s ability to handle a heavier workload. Historically, Allen’s performance drops when overused, which could impact New Jersey’s win totals and early-season odds.

Yes, the Devils’ regular season win total is expected to decrease after trading Jacob Markstrom. With Allen as the new starter and backup uncertainty, bettors should monitor sportsbooks for value on the under if win totals remain high.

The trade moves the Devils from a stable goaltending situation to a high-variance one. Early-season betting odds may lag behind this change, so sharp bettors can find value by fading the Devils’ moneyline or betting overs until lines are adjusted.

Nico Daws and David Rittich are the likely backup options now that Jake Allen is starting. Daws has shown promise in small windows but lacks proven durability, while Rittich is an experienced, but inconsistent, veteran backup.

According to the latest reports and BDL LIVE_DATA, Jake Allen, Nico Daws, and David Rittich are all healthy; there are no significant outstanding goalie injuries for the Devils heading into the season. Depth, however, remains thin after Markstrom’s trade.

For the 2026 season, the New Jersey Devils’ goalie roster includes Jake Allen as the starter, with Nico Daws and David Rittich in backup and rotation roles after the Jacob Markstrom trade. None have an established steady starting resume comparable to Markstrom.