September 20, 2026 • 2:01 PM EDT
Updated 1 hours ago
Both Bullpens Are Running on Fumes, Here’s Where That Leaves Bettors Today
The Washington Nationals face the St. Louis Cardinals in the series finale on Sunday, September 20 at Busch Stadium, with both teams scrambling for fresh arms after a bruising week of late-inning drama. The Nationals are one win away from a sweep, riding a 6-4 stretch in their last ten, and taking full advantage of a Cardinals bullpen short on both health and answers.
The numbers say it all: the Nationals have a crowded IL with multiple relievers down, and the Cardinals are missing key bullpen arms. BDL data confirms these are not minor scrapes, major contributors are out, and recent games have forced both squads well into backup territory. Expect more lineup mixing, with the Nationals leaning righty-heavy and the Cardinals plugging in any functional lefty they can find.
For bettors, this is the part that matters: you can throw out half your usual late-game analysis. Relief pitching is a minefield right now. Every fresh call to the pen carries risk, whether it’s a rookie on three days’ rest or a middle reliever pressed into a ninth-inning save chance. The edge shifts hard toward the first five innings, before fatigue or panic sets in, and when today’s starters still have something in the tank.
The First Five Innings Define This Matchup: Full-Game Totals Are a Trap
Related: Nationals’ Bullpen Meltdown Cements First-Five Edges: Best Bets for Washington-St. Louis Today
Look for volatility when the starters come out. Pitchers for both teams are under pressure to deliver length, but with rookie arms and bench pieces getting key spots, there’s no reason to trust a full-game under or over, odds will be skewed by bullpen uncertainty that’s baked into the late lines.
The Cardinals come in on a four-game losing streak, the Nationals are using their winning momentum to mask some deep holes in their relief corps, and both managers are juggling lineups to maximize split advantages early. Hitters see these bullpen gaps too; expect aggressive swings in the later innings, but only if the score is tight.
The last week reads like a script: tight games go late, relievers lose command, and leads don’t hold. When IL stints cluster and streaks go bust, every inning after the fifth is chaos you do not want to price in.
Key Developments Backing the First Five Edge
- The Nationals and Cardinals have multiple relievers on the IL: late-inning volatility is at its peak.
- Nationals are 6-4 over their last 10, with comeback wins: early leads matter.
- Cardinals on a four-game losing streak and lineup disruptions: the F5 moneyline favors a sharp Nationals angle.
- Both teams shifting lineups (Nats righty-heavy, Cards lefty-heavier): early split edges could decide the first five.
- Recent bullpen usage for both sides among the highest of the week: full-game totals risk wild swings late.
Key Takeaways: Where to Put Your Money
- Target the First Five Innings (F5) under 4.5 at standard lines for maximum stability.
- Lean Nats F5 -0.5 moneyline if it’s posted, avoid full-game bets today.
- Fade full-game overs and unders: bullpen chaos after inning five makes outcomes unpredictable.
- Monitor injury updates on relievers for both teams before live betting any late-game total.
- Don’t chase late-run props: bench players and rookie relievers open the door to odd blow-ups.
- Revisit the latest Nationals and Cardinals picks and season record for a running log of sharp edges and updated lines.
“It’s a challenge, for sure. We’re running out of bullets in the pen.”Manager quote, per Yahoo Sports
This article was produced with AI assistance by Pritish Ganguly, with editorial standards and betting methodology overseen by Richard Gale (senior gambling industry executive, ThePicks founder), and reviewed by the ThePicks editorial team. All statistics sourced from live BDL API data and verified source material. All betting opinions are those of ThePicks analysts.
https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/washington-nationals-vs-st-louis-174500315.html
21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.
Login 
