September 17, 2026 • 6:04 PM EDT
Updated 1 hours ago
Ready for September baseball that has real stakes? The Phillies roll into New York on Thursday night to start a four-game series at Citi Field with the Mets. Both clubs are eyeing playoff positions, and this set could have a big impact on how the race looks at the end of the week.
Aaron Nola gets the ball for the Phillies. Nola’s the kind of pitcher you want leading off a huge road series—he works fast, he’s composed, and he’s proven he can beat the Mets. But, the stats say it’s not automatic. So far this season, Nola has faced New York twice and posted a 4.09 ERA in those outings. What’s that tell you? He’s been solid but not lights-out, and you can expect the Mets to come in with a plan.
On the other side, the Mets hand the ball to Nolan McLean. He’s a young righty in his second big-league campaign, but his numbers are nothing to sneeze at: 11-9 with a 3.24 ERA. That tells you McLean’s been a stabilizer for New York’s rotation. If you’re looking for value plays or thinking about the total, keep in mind that McLean has shown he can go deep into games and keep things tight on the scoreboard.
This is the matchup FOX wanted in primetime for a reason. Both teams send quality starters and these head-to-heads down the stretch decide playoff spots, especially in the NL East. According to Yahoo Sports, first pitch is set for 7:15 PM and will be aired nationwide.
The Phillies announced their confidence with a night-in-New-York post that said it all—Nola’s their man. The Mets, meanwhile, are hyped for the series opener, knowing every game counts as they try to gain ground in the division. What should you watch for? Pay attention to how Nola handles the pressure and whether McLean can keep the ball in the yard against a patient Phillies lineup.
- Aaron Nola starts for the Phillies, sporting a 4.09 ERA in two outings versus the Mets this year.
- Nolan McLean counters for the Mets, entering with an 11-9 record and 3.24 ERA this season.
- The Phillies and Mets kick off a four-game series that could shape the playoff picture.
- Game time is 7:15 PM, broadcast nationally on FOX.
Pitching matchup in focus
You can’t overstate how much the starting pitchers matter in a series like this. Nola thrives in pressure spots but hasn’t dominated the Mets this year. For the Phillies to set the tone, he needs to work ahead and keep the Citi Field energy from turning against him. Don’t ignore the fact that the Mets offense will likely test him early.
McLean might not have the name recognition of Nola, but his consistency is why the Mets trust him in this spot. With a 3.24 ERA, you know McLean’s got the ability to keep the game close. If he can settle in early, it could be a long night for Philly bats.
Why this series matters
This isn’t just another series in September. Four games between NL East rivals this late can swing momentum and playoff probability. Every inning, every mound visit, every big swing counts double when there’s not much margin left in the season.
Key takeaways
- Both teams have reliable right-handers taking the mound, which suggests a low-scoring series opener.
- Nola’s history this season against the Mets indicates neither side has a clear pitching edge.
- National TV spot means more eyes and more pressure—momentum could change quickly based on early runs.
- Look for tight management, with both teams trying to grab game one for a mental edge.
- The series’ outcome may set the tone for NL East playoff jockeying over the last two weeks.
- Backing either starting pitcher for strikeouts could offer value depending on the lineup cards.
- First-inning scoring—or lack thereof—will be a tone-setter for bettors playing the under.
- Don’t expect a bullpen game unless the starters struggle early—their pitch counts shouldn’t be managed lightly in a series with this much riding on it.
- Momentum from Thursday’s result could bleed into the weekend, so keep an eye on how both managers handle late-inning decisions.
More coverage: more MLB headlines, our MLB betting analysis and MLB picks and predictions.
Related stories
21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.
Login 
