By Pritish Ganguly

August 27, 2026 • 9:04 AM EDT

Updated 2 hours ago

Bo Bichette exited Wednesday’s Mets-Brewers game at Citi Field with a left foot contusion and is listed day-to-day for Thursday’s August 27 series finale, dealing another blow to a New York Mets lineup that is already operating without Juan Soto, Jorge Polanco, and Mark Vientos.

The Mets are 60-73 on the season, averaging just 4.14 runs per game. The Brewers are 82-51, leading the NL Central, and averaging 4.96 runs scored against a 3.71 runs-allowed clip. When you strip the Mets’ roster down to what they’re actually putting on the field Thursday, this isn’t a 7.5-run game.

Jacob Misiorowski takes the mound for Milwaukee against Sean Manaea. Misiorowski is a power arm with ace-level upside. Manaea is a quality veteran who limits damage. The Mets’ depleted lineup facing Misiorowski is the most important data point in this game: a team averaging 4.14 runs per game, missing its three most dangerous offensive contributors, does not hang five or six on a pitcher of his caliber. That’s the number. That’s where the value lives.

The Brewers’ bullpen is also running thinner than normal after Dustin May took a 106-mph line drive off his right shoulder and left Wednesday’s game after a single pitch. Milwaukee burned extra arms a day early. Their IL has already swallowed Uribe (forearm), Fitzpatrick (Tommy John), Zerpa (Tommy John), Zastryzny (shoulder), and Romero, who is on a rehab assignment after an appendectomy. That’s five relievers unavailable. The fresh arms Thursday are limited, but Misiorowski going deep into the game is the most logical outcome, and that actually strengthens the under case, not the over.

Why Bichette’s Foot Contusion Changes Your Prop Bets Before You Lock Anything In

Related: Fernando Cruz UCL Tear Leaves Yankees Bullpen Exposed Tonight: Two Bets to Make Now

Bichette’s injury may not draw the headlines Soto’s calf strain did, but it’s the overnight news the market hasn’t fully priced. When a player fouls a ball off his foot hard enough to exit the game mid-contest, the discomfort doesn’t disappear by first pitch the next day. Even if he’s in the lineup, he’s compromised: his plate approach tightens, his ability to drive the ball to the pull side is affected, and he’s not running out grounders with full aggression.

His season line sits at .268/.314/.398 with 14 home runs and 66 RBI. That’s the production the Mets can least afford to lose given everything else going on. But the prop angle is the sharper play here. Sportsbooks set Bichette’s over 0.5 hits at somewhere in the -160 to -180 range given his recent form. Fading that on any positive line is a value play when the player literally hobbled off the field 18 hours ago. If he’s scratched entirely, those props void: monitor the lineup before kickoff.

The Mets’ bullpen compounds the problem in the opposite direction. Edwin Diaz (shoulder) and Carlos Perez (forearm) are both on the IL. The back end of New York’s bullpen is patchwork. But that’s a risk that cuts both ways: if Manaea is sharp early and the Brewers can’t chase him, a Brewers lineup hitting 4.96 runs per game average could be contained in a low-scoring game. The Mets’ bullpen vulnerability matters more in a high-variance opener than in a Manaea quality-start scenario.

The Under Holds Up Whether Bichette Plays or Sits

My read on this is straightforward: the under on the game total (expected at 7.5 or 8, -110 to -115) holds up across both Bichette scenarios. If he plays, he’s limited. If he sits, the Mets’ lineup is historically thin. Misiorowski suppresses, Manaea competes, and both bullpens are taxed enough to keep this from becoming a late-innings scoring fest. The Brewers’ potency (7-3 last 10 games) keeps this from being a Mets-win lean, and the Mets’ 6-4 last-10 showing is not enough to flip the moneyline value.

I’m on the under in Mets vs. Brewers Game 3, but watch the Bichette lineup confirmation in the final hour before first pitch. If he’s out, the secondary prop plays are off the board, but the under gets stronger. If he’s in, the prop fade on his hits total becomes the sharper add-on bet. The full Milwaukee and New York updated lines and records are on the Mets vs. Brewers MLB picks page.

Key Developments

• Bo Bichette is day-to-day with a left foot contusion after exiting Wednesday’s game early: his hit props and total-bases props are compromised regardless of whether he starts Thursday. Fade the over on 0.5 hits at any positive line.
• Dustin May took a 106-mph line drive off his right shoulder and exited after one pitch Wednesday, though X-rays were negative: Milwaukee burned bullpen arms a day early, reducing Thursday’s bridge depth behind Misiorowski.
• Jacob Misiorowski starts Game 3 for the Brewers against a lineup missing Soto (calf, IL), Polanco (ankle surgery, season done), and potentially Bichette: Misiorowski’s strikeout props and the under deserve serious attention.
• The Mets are averaging 4.14 runs per game across a 60-73 season: facing an ace-caliber arm with their three best offensive contributors unavailable, the Mets’ team total under is the cleanest bet on the board.
• Five Brewers relievers are on the IL (Uribe, Fitzpatrick, Zerpa, Zastryzny, Romero): Milwaukee’s depth is thin, but Misiorowski going seven-plus innings is the most plausible path and that supports, not undermines, the under.
• Juan Soto took live BP at Citi Field on Wednesday, progressing toward activation: he does not return for Thursday’s game, so his rehab milestone has no impact on the series finale lineup.

Key Takeaways

• Back the under on the Mets vs. Brewers game total (7.5 or 8, -110 to -115): Misiorowski pitching against a lineup missing Soto, Polanco, and a compromised Bichette is the clearest betting edge in this game.
• Fade the Bichette over 0.5 hits prop at any positive line: a player who exits a game with a foot injury is not operating at full plate capacity the following afternoon, regardless of the day-to-day label.
• Monitor the Mets lineup release in the final 60-90 minutes before first pitch: Bichette’s presence or absence changes the prop landscape significantly, and the lineup release is your final confirmation signal.
• Target Misiorowski strikeout props if his line reflects a depleted opponent: a full-strength Mets lineup is a mediocre strikeout matchup, but this is not a full-strength Mets lineup. The gap is meaningful.
• Skip the Mets moneyline entirely: 60-73, missing their three most productive hitters, against the NL’s best team. The implied value is nowhere near the actual risk.
• Do not overweight the Brewers bullpen depletion on the over: the same depletion that makes Milwaukee’s late-game arms thin also means Misiorowski will be asked to go deep, which keeps run totals down, not up.
• Treat the Brewers moneyline as fair value but not the sharp play: Milwaukee is the right side but the juice on an 82-51 favorite on the road against a 60-73 team is priced in. The under gives you more bang for the analysis.

“X-rays came back negative. It’s a bruise. He could be back within a few days.”Curt Hogg, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, on Dustin May’s shoulder injury

This article was produced with AI assistance by Pritish Ganguly, with editorial standards and betting methodology overseen by Richard Gale (senior gambling industry executive, ThePicks founder), and reviewed by the ThePicks editorial team. All statistics sourced from live BDL API data and verified source material. All betting opinions are those of ThePicks analysts.

https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/mets-morning-news-mets-suffer-123000535.html

21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.