September 16, 2026 • 6:04 AM EDT
Updated 1 hours ago
Finding a reliable catcher has been a sticking point for the Pittsburgh Pirates lately. That’s why the buzz around Easton Carmichael stands out. After just two pro seasons, Carmichael is firmly on the radar as Pittsburgh’s potential answer behind the plate. The kid’s already shown why he’s not just another catcher in the system but possibly the Pirates’ best solution in years.
Drafted in the third round in 2025 after a notable career at the University of Oklahoma, Carmichael came in with a reputation. He’s not just a defender — he was listed among the top 100 prospects ahead of that draft and even took home MVP honors at the Cape Cod League All-Star Game while still in college. The Pirates clearly saw something major, and he’s started to reward them for the pick. According to Yahoo Sports, Carmichael is now the eighth-best prospect in the Bucs’ system.
Now, I know what you’re wondering — can he hit? After a frustrating wrist injury kept him out most of his debut, he bounced back strong in 2026. With High-A Greensboro, Carmichael batted .305/.350/.518, slugged 16 homers in just 74 games, and posted a crisp .868 OPS. That’s not just good for a catcher, that’s legit power and consistency at the plate by any measure.
Carmichael earned his promotion to Double-A Altoona on July 24, where he’s been adjusting to tougher pitching. Through 37 games with the Curve, his numbers have cooled: a .244 average, .313 OBP, and just four homers. That dip’s real, but it’s also completely normal for a second-year pro facing better arms. He’s not lost — he’s learning, and the foundation’s set. When Altoona Curve hyped his fourth Double-A homer, it marked his twentieth total in 2026 — a number scouts love to see in a young backstop.
- Carmichael went from High-A standout to Double-A regular in one year.
- He hit 16 homers at Greensboro, then added four more with Altoona for 20 total.
- His overall slash line shows impressive power and on-base skills for a young catcher.
- Despite a wrist injury in 2025, he rebounded quickly and consistently with the bat.
- Now assigned to the Arizona Fall League, where many Pirates prospects have taken big steps forward.
- Currently ranked eighth among all Pirates prospects.
The Arizona Fall League Test
Getting a spot with the Glendale Desert Dogs in the Arizona Fall League is no small call. That league is loaded with talent — the kind of place where raw skills get refined and stars start to separate from the pack. The Pirates have sent plenty of rising names through AFL, and Carmichael could be next to shine if he grabs the opportunity.
What Scouts Like About Carmichael
Carmichael’s profile is what you want in a modern catcher. Athleticism that’s above average for the position, a strong arm, and an advanced approach at the plate. He’s not just swinging for fences; he’s disciplined, waiting for his pitch. There are rough edges defensively, especially with his receiving and glove work, but those are normal tweaks for a catcher at his age. The key — and the reason to stay bullish — is that none of these issues look like red flags. It’s all coachable stuff, not limits to his ceiling.
What It Means for Pirates Fans and Bettors
Depth at catcher matters if you’re watching prospect futures or even just following Pittsburgh’s rebuild. Carmichael’s power and approach suggest he’s got a real shot, especially if he holds his own in the AFL. That keeps the long-term outlook strong at a spot where the Bucs have needed a steady presence for years. Bettors and fans should pay close attention to his Arizona Fall League performance. If he keeps trending up, he’ll climb prospect charts and maybe even fast-track himself for a Pittsburgh debut sooner than most expected.
- Carmichael could solve the Pirates’ long-term catcher issue if his power and approach hold at higher levels.
- Keep an eye on his AFL stint — it’s a proving ground that matters both to scouts and future bettors.
- He profiles as a true all-around backstop: athletic, disciplined, and with real pop at the plate.
- His injury setback hasn’t slowed his climb — in fact, it makes his breakout more promising.
- The Double-A learning curve is just that: a curve, not a wall.
- If Carmichael’s receiving skills round out, he’s an everyday MLB possibility.
More coverage: latest MLB news, our MLB betting analysis and MLB picks and predictions.
Related stories
21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.
Login 
