September 23, 2026 • 9:02 AM EDT
Updated 1 hours ago
The Cleveland Cavaliers have pushed their chips to the middle of the table. After getting dismantled by the New York Knicks in the Eastern Conference Finals and losing key rotation players, this front office decided to swing big. Gone is the hesitation; Cleveland decided it’s now or never.
Make no mistake, this is the most all-in the Cavs have been since their last true title run. They lost critical depth this offseason, including connector Dean Wade and versatile Keon Ellis, and struck out on any LeBron James reunion. Meanwhile, rivals like the 76ers, Raptors, and Celtics just kept getting better. If the playoffs showed us anything, it’s that the Cavaliers were close but still a tier below the real contenders.
According to Yahoo! Sports, the front office didn’t just accept that window slamming shut. Instead, they pulled off a five-team trade to land Peyton Watson, the hottest two-way wing available, at the cost of Dennis Schroder, Max Strus, and future picks. They doubled down again, swapping Darius Garland for James Harden, then extended both Harden and Donovan Mitchell. In short, the Cavs spent just about every asset they could. Now they sit with a starry but top-heavy roster. The question: will it work?
This season comes down to one thing: Peyton Watson’s impact. Since his days as a Denver Nugget, Watson has drawn comparisons to a young Jonathan Isaac for his length and defensive instincts. He’s racked up top block percentages despite not playing center and regularly takes on the toughest perimeter matchups. His January outburst—21.9 points, 5.5 boards, 3 assists, and 1.5 blocks per game on efficient shooting—puts him in rare company. Only a handful of players under 24 have strung together such numbers in the pace-and-space era, and nearly all became All-Stars. But, it’s a small sample, and postseason injuries kept us from seeing that game translate under real pressure.
Watson doesn’t need to be the primary scorer; that’s Harden or Mitchell’s job. But if Watson can repeat last year’s shooting jump (41.1 percent on 3.6 threes a game), he instantly becomes the best starting wing the Cavs have had since their championship core. If that number is just a blip, and he reverts to his old averages, the “non-shooter” label could hang around and limit Cleveland’s ceiling.
It’s not just Watson the Cavs need to click. Their starting center, Allen, is about as steady as they come—lock him in for another top-10 year at his position. Harden, even at 37, brings consistent playmaking, but he’s at the age where significant decline is always a risk. Any step back from Harden or Mitchell (now nearly 30 and known for his boom-or-bust playoff runs) heaps more weight on Watson. Plus, Mobley has to rediscover his 2024-25 dominance after slipping well down the impact rankings last season. He can’t afford to be passive while this team bets the farm.
- The Cavaliers reached their first Eastern Conference Finals since 2018 but were outclassed by the Knicks
- Key role players (Wade, Ellis) left, and Cleveland failed to land LeBron James
- A five-team deal brought in defensive specialist Peyton Watson at a heavy cost
- Darius Garland was swapped for James Harden, who was then extended along with Donovan Mitchell
- Lineup now features Watson, Harden, Mitchell, Mobley, and Allen—easily the most talented five in years but with suspect depth
Depth is the big concern. Jaylon Tyson showed promising growth, jumping from the 14th to 77th percentile in EPM, and Sam Merrill will keep spacing the floor even with his defensive holes. After that, Cleveland relies on a mix of untested players and hopes at least one punches above their weight. They can’t survive a major injury, so staying healthy is non-negotiable.
Evaluating the New Cavaliers Core
Look at where the sportsbooks put them: FanDuel says Cleveland has the sixth-best shot in the East at +900 odds, roughly 10 percent. That seems low to me given their renewed firepower. The Knicks and Raptors might be in their own class, but the Cavs belong right there with the Celtics, 76ers, and Pacers. Stack their starting five up against anyone in that second tier, and I’d argue Cleveland comes out on top on talent alone.
Last year, Cleveland ran out a top-6 offense but a middling defense. Watson’s addition goes a long way to balancing that with more defensive muscle, and while losing Strus hurts their offense, having Harden for a full year plus Tyson’s growth should keep them near the elite. There’s a realistic scenario where the Cavaliers become a top 10 unit on both sides—something precious few teams in this conference can claim. If their bench holds up and everyone stays upright, this could be the most well-rounded Cavs squad since the LeBron-led years.
If It Doesn’t Work, What’s Next?
It’s all a dice roll now. Cleveland’s gone all-in and bet on top-end talent, knowing they can’t tinker anymore if it falls flat. If Watson lives up to his potential, and the stars stay healthy, you’re suddenly looking at a real contender. But if the bench collapses, or stars age quickly, the teardown talk won’t be far behind. This is what high-level betting looks like—no hedging, no safety net. For the 2026-27 Cavs, it’s championship or bust.
More coverage: latest NBA news, NBA analysis and odds and NBA expert picks.
Related stories
21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.
Login 
