September 12, 2026 • 6:01 PM EDT
Updated 1 hours ago
Cubs Storm Back Against Pirates in Eighth: Why Injuries Shifted Betting Edges Today
The Chicago Cubs pulled off a dramatic 4-3 comeback win over the Pittsburgh Pirates on Saturday at Wrigley Field, capitalizing on another late-game bullpen collapse just when it mattered most. Both teams came in missing key arms, six for the Cubs, four for the Pirates, and it showed the moment it got tight in the eighth inning.
The numbers don’t hide what happened: the Cubs have now posted 42 come-from-behind wins this season, one of the highest totals in baseball. They’re 4-6 in their last 10, but that’s misleading when you look under the hood. Almost every loss and win in September has come down to frantic bullpen innings with patchwork arms closing games. The Pirates, despite a recent 7-3 run, have also been undone by their battered bullpen. With guys like Paul Skenes dropping in velocity and stars like Yates and Rodriguez sidelined, they’ve coughed up late leads repeatedly.
What’s this mean if you’re betting these two? The advantage is squarely in live markets, the classic pregame moneyline does not price in the nightly volatility. The oddsmakers are still hanging base-level totals and Cubs slight favorites (-145, 8.5 O/U) even while both clubs run out relievers with little setup experience. It’s a live-bettor’s dream: watch for close games through five, then hit Cubs comeback or overs once managers turn to the back end of their bullpens.
Let’s be clear: this isn’t fluke variance. The Cubs’ manager, Craig Counsell, has been running a closer-by-committee out of necessity. There’s no reliable shutdown option. BDL data confirms relievers like Hodge, Horton, Brown, Martin, Harvey, and Maton are missing for Chicago. Pittsburgh counters with their own patchwork, including losing Mitch Keller, who is out, and suffering a setup loss with Yates, so neither side has any real ninth-inning certainty. Both teams are on high alert for matchups, not established roles. The comebacks are no accident.
Every Stat Signals: Late-Inning Action Is Where the Value Lives
Related: Edward Cabrera’s Return Transforms Cubs Bullpen: Why Tonight’s Moneyline Carries More Weight
Look at the recent splits: the Cubs have played a dozen close games in the last three weeks, and the Pirates can’t hold tight leads with three-plus arms down. Skenes’ velocity dip and late fatigue only pile on the late chaos. What’s more, neither offense is particularly imposing early, so first five innings often settle little, and bullpen matchups (or mismatches) are where these games are won, lost, and bet.
The way I see it: sharp bettors aren’t choosing sides at first pitch. They’re waiting until reliever chaos is looming in the sixth or seventh. Cubs comeback props, Pirates bullpen fades, and live overs when games are tied or within a run are all getting hit hard by in-the-know market movers.
- The Cubs have 42 come-from-behind wins this season: late live moneylines are underpriced when they trail.
- Both bullpens are missing at least three high-leverage arms: volatility near the end is not baked into pregame lines.
- Cubs are only 4-6 in last 10 but have rallied for three late wins despite those losses: that comeback profile is real for live bettors.
- Pirates’ 7-3 run hides multiple blown saves: their bullpen is leaking hits and runs late, giving live overs an edge.
- Skenes’ velocity drop in recent starts reduces early edge for Pirates, especially when bullpen injuries hit by the 6th.
- Craig Counsell has used a closer-by-committee for weeks: Cubs’ final three innings are always matchup-driven, ready for comeback or collapse.
The Picks Firm Call: Bet Cubs Comebacks and Live Overs After the Sixth, The Bullpen Math Is on Your Side
Back the Cubs live after the sixth inning when they’re trailing or tied. The data is clear: Chicago’s comeback rate and both teams’ injury-ravaged bullpens make comeback and live over bets the highest-value plays. Avoid chasing pregame run-lines unless you’re specifically targeting late-inning action. The full track record and updated numbers are on the Chicago Cubs picks and season record.
“We’re mixing and matching late… everyone is on alert for spots.”Craig Counsell, Chicago Cubs manager
- Keep pregame bets light: the real edge is in late-game live betting on Cubs vs. Pirates.
- Play Cubs live moneyline when they trail or are tied after the sixth: comeback frequency is elite.
- Target live overs if both teams are close heading into the seventh: bullpens can’t be counted on to close without giving up runs.
- Fade Pirates’ bullpen protects: blown saves and velocity drops are trending up.
- Monitor injury news right before lineup lock: key bullpen adds or returns will swing value direction quickly.
- Watch for sudden closer reallocations for the Cubs, Counsell is still searching for answers in the ninth.
This article was produced with AI assistance by Pritish Ganguly, with editorial standards and betting methodology overseen by Richard Gale (senior gambling industry executive, ThePicks founder), and reviewed by the ThePicks editorial team. All statistics sourced from live BDL API data and verified source material. All betting opinions are those of ThePicks analysts.
https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/cubs-4-pirates-3-hit-214036496.html
21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.
Login 
