By Ben Gale

September 2, 2026 • 12:02 PM EDT

Updated 5 days ago

The Steelers Traded Broderick Jones and It Should Change How You See Their Season Odds

The Pittsburgh Steelers sent offensive tackle Broderick Jones to the Dallas Cowboys on Tuesday, just days after drafting his replacement and declining his fifth-year option. This wasn’t a minor transaction. For Steelers backers, it rewrites the starting lineup and drops Pittsburgh’s offensive line from a strength to a question mark, at least in the early weeks of 2026.

Here’s the data layer: Pittsburgh finished 10-7 last year with Jones in the rotation, but the team’s offensive line lost its primary backup and is now betting on a rookie starter, Max Iheanachor, at tackle. Injuries aren’t minor: multiple starters on this unit and the receiving corps are either questionable or sidelined heading into camp. Dallas gains roster insurance by adding Jones, but he’s not secured a starting job and the Cowboys’ O-line is carrying its own injury baggage, meaning no instant quality boost.

The betting implication is clear. Sportsbooks are slow to reprice for this level of depth shakeup, especially in the trenches. Right now, the market still values Pittsburgh’s offensive line as stable off last season’s record. That’s false security. The minute oddsmakers factor in a rookie tackle, a thinner rotation, and cluster injuries on the outside, you’re going to see the Steelers’ season win total and early spreads start to tick down. Sharp money is already looking to fade Pittsburgh in games against teams with serious pass rushes. Dallas, meanwhile, doesn’t warrant an immediate bump: Jones has to win a job first, and the Cowboys’ O-line remains in flux until camp shakes out.

This Isn’t a Neutral Depth Chart Swap, It Exposes the Steelers Early

Related: Joey Porter Jr.’s Week 1 Status Looms Over Steelers Defense: Why the Edge Moves for Opponent Props Tonight

Jones’s struggles in Pittsburgh were about positional instability. He never settled cleanly at guard, left tackle, or right tackle, bouncing in and out of the lineup. The Steelers declining his fifth-year option wasn’t a surprise, but trading him after drafting Max Iheanachor says the team is choosing potential over experience, for better or worse. Iheanachor might have talent, but a rookie tackle sees more stunts and blitzes right out of the gate. That puts extra pressure on Pittsburgh’s offensive gameplan whenever facing a top-12 pass rush. Add injuries to the receiving corps, and the ball may not come out as fast as the scheme needs.

Bettors shouldn’t ignore the risk here. The O-line is football’s most fragile chemistry experiment, and Pittsburgh’s just lost a critical piece of that stability. Fade the Steelers’ spread as favorites against teams with dominant pass-rushing units. The Cowboys, for their part, are getting more lottery ticket than locked-in solution. Jones was acquired for depth, and that depth only becomes a betting factor if injuries strike elsewhere in Dallas’s starting five.

Key Developments

• Pittsburgh traded Broderick Jones after drafting Max Iheanachor: Steelers shift from experience to a rookie at tackle, lowering O-line stability for early games.
• The team declined Jones’s fifth-year option before the deal: Signals a lack of trust in his positional fit and future, impacting O-line depth projection for 2026.
• Pittsburgh finished 10-7 last year, now faces WR and O-line injuries: These cluster injuries amplify O-line risk and make spreads versus good pass rushes dangerous to back.
• Dallas’s O-line isn’t at full strength either: Jones is roster insurance, not a guaranteed starter, don’t price in a Cowboys futures upgrade yet.
• Bookmakers aren’t yet adjusting Steelers win totals: Early bettors can target soft lines before preseason injuries and rookie struggles reset the markets.

Key Takeaways

• Fade the Pittsburgh Steelers against above-average pass rushes early in the season.
• Target under on the Steelers’ early season win total if offered at 9.5 or 10.
• Monitor rookie Max Iheanachor’s performance before backing Pittsburgh spreads.
• Avoid upgrading Dallas’s win total or division futures on this trade alone, wait for injury news and camp depth chart moves.
• Check injury reports for Pittsburgh receivers and tackles before building any prop parlays relying on their pass game.
• Track preseason O-line rotations and camp battles for both teams to spot actionable line moves.
• Watch divisional futures: AFC North odds may shift against the Steelers as market consensus catches up.

I’m on the fade for Pittsburgh spreads here, but watch for how Max Iheanachor and the reconfigured O-line hold up before taking a full-size under on the win total. The Pittsburgh Steelers picks and season record has everything you need before you confirm the bet.

“I took everything I could from Pittsburgh, learned a lot. Ready to compete for Dallas.”Broderick Jones, Offensive Tackle

This article was produced with AI assistance by Ben Gale, with editorial standards and betting methodology overseen by Richard Gale (senior gambling industry executive, ThePicks founder), and reviewed by the ThePicks editorial team. All statistics sourced from live BDL API data and verified source material. All betting opinions are those of ThePicks analysts.

https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/broderick-jones-explains-went-wrong-153207492.html

21+ only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We may earn a commission from affiliate links.